regression imputation for missing data

Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. A you can see, it worked like a charm. Control that no data is missing by using mno.matrix(deter_data, figsize = (20,5)) as above. However, it should be stressed that it is an INDICATION, not a proof. Select at least two variables in the imputation model. The problem is that variables might be correlated and if one attempts to impute one variable using another (correlated) variable which also lacks data, problems will just add up. Considering that the missing rate is not high (14.6%), 10-time MI could be sufficient to perform the imputation- according to a rule of thumb by Rubin - with a multinomial logistic regression for predicting the missing values and a logistic regression model for predicting the missingness probability with non-zero weights, e.g., (0.4,0.4;0.2). arrow_right_alt. Did you read the reference I cited? Because it simplifies life and we are lazy by nature. Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! At least, the experience has the merit of being humbling and inspiring at the same time. This simply means that the observed non-missing data is a random sample of the entire population and that any analysis made on the existing data is unbaised. How can i extract files in the directory where they're located with the find command? This is a preference based on the data. , since both Ozone and Solar.R are missing !. Multiple imputation (MI) is now widely used to handle missing data in longitudinal studies. calculated from the observed data. However, the parameter estimators do not converge point-wise and are not efficient for finite imputation size m. but MCAR-data is a rare thing. Topics: Data. This works by imputing all missing values with zero, the mean or median for quantitative variables, or the most common value for categorical variables. . What is regression imputation? Thanks for contributing an answer to Cross Validated! The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? First, we assign a relevance to the target variable values . To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. To get a better view of the distribution of values of each variable we produce a description of the dataset: We can here see that the variable cylinder has a maximum value of 100 (there are no vehicles with 100 cylinder), the variable horsepower has a maximum of 100000 (which also is unlikely) and finally, the weight of any car cannot be 0. Most often, the level of crappiness has to do with missing data and or eroneous values. Why? For an arbitrary missing . Data can go missing due to incomplete data entry, equipment malfunctions, lost files, and many other reasons. 5 0 obj The four methods are: Predict. MISSING DATA, IMPUTATION AND REGRESSION TREES Wei-Yin Loh1, Qiong Zhang2, Wenwen Zhang3 and Peigen Zhou1 1University of Wisconsin, Madison, 2Clemson University and 3Takeda Abstract: Missing data are a major hindrance to statistical analysis because stan-dard methods require the missing values to be imputed rst. The strength of the relationships could inform how important a predictor was in the regression imputation models. We start by creating an catalogue of the columns lacking data: and create a function for the radom imputation: Remember that these values are randomly chosen from the non-missing data in each column. Instead of deleting any case that has any missing value, this approach preserves all cases by replacing the missing data with a probable value estimated by other available information. stream More precisely, I'm going to investigate the popularity of the following five imputation methods: Mean Imputation Regression Imp. So your value is not imputed. In this chapter we discuss avariety ofmethods to handle missing data, including some relativelysimple approaches that can often yield reasonable results. In large epidemiologic studies, data collection almost inevitably is plagued by missing data, for example, due to item nonresponse. perform the desired analysis on each data set by using standard, complete data methods. Stack Overflow for Teams is moving to its own domain! Missing values may occur because of non-response, errors in the data collection, or dropout. There is, however, a more elegant way to handle a situation in which data is missing for several feature and the relationship between the variables is not evident. So your value is not imputed. As the examples above are easy to perform, they do come with an array of problems and questions. Are cheap electric helicopters feasible to produce? PROS: The complete removal of data with missing values results in very accurate model.for the data they have been presented. This class also allows for different missing values encodings. Some coworkers are committing to work overtime for a 1% bonus. The vector containing the $n_1$ observed data in $y$ is denoted by $y_{obs}$ , and the vector of $n_0$ imputed values in $y$ is indicated by $\dot{y}$. that it is either MAR or MNAR. So, talking about random forest models and neural networks with some examples would just feel like another boring lecture or textbook demo. With regression imputation the information of other variables is used to predict the missing values in a variable by using a regression model. The basic idea behind this method is to use information from all observations with complete values in the variables of interest to fill in the incomplete values which is intuitively appealingly (Frane 1976 ). It explains the algorithm step for step. We use as a running example the Social Indicators Survey, a telephone survey of New York City families . Several different approaches to imputing missing values are found in the literature: 1. Now we can generate a random dataset, add 10% missing data and shuffle it all together. 2- Regression Imputation: the missing value is replaced for the predicted value generated by the regression of the missing item on items observed for the unit. There are many sophisticated methods exist to handle missing values in longitudinal data. In this way, MI creates values for the missing data that preserve the inherent characteristics of the variables (means, variance, etc.). How to distinguish it-cleft and extraposition? It has nothing to do with what is measured or by whom the instrument is operated. Single imputation is a general term that describes a family of missing data replacement techniques, including last value replacement, mean replacement, and single regression replacement. Missing data is a common problem in applied research. The augmented data matrix is used to determine the lowest degree polynomial adequate to fit the average growth curve (AGC); the regression coefficients are estimated and confidence intervals for them are determined; and confidence bands for the AGC are constructed. Found footage movie where teens get superpowers after getting struck by lightning? Imputing for Missing Items In most surveys there will be items for which respondents do not provide information, even though the respondent completed enough of the data collection instrument to be considered "complete". Instruments, for example, can have a limited range of observation and anything measured falling out of this range will be recorded as missing. or this one. Revised on October 10, 2022. If only the cases with all items present are retained when fitting a model, quite a few cases may be excluded from the analysis. When the migration is complete, you will access your Teams at stackoverflowteams.com, and they will no longer appear in the left sidebar on stackoverflow.com. MathJax reference. The four methods are: Predict. I4u(k"q>:TyJ7E+HF21s !;+Oo Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. (>Fn*8:8.d587DDhwf9RKicEw6q1D,`Q+soc;Zs[}MZ. The problem is that variables might be correlated and if one attempts to impute one variable using another (correlated) variable which also lacks data, problems will just add up. It only takes a minute to sign up. arrow_right_alt. Can I spend multiple charges of my Blood Fury Tattoo at once? Multiple imputation is a popular approach to handling missing data in medical research, yet little is known about its applicability for estimating the relative risk. Mobile app infrastructure being decommissioned, Handling missing data for participants who have not completed any standardised measures and have only provided demographic answers, Pooling imputed, still not analysed datasets in MICE, Multiple Imputation and Regression Model Diagnostics, Imputation and linear regression analysis paradox, Compare the output of a pooled model after multiple imputation vs model on combined long dataset, Using regression for imputing missing data. Thanks for contributing an answer to Cross Validated! Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. There are things you may do to give you hints, but they are in no way a clear-cut answer. MIDASpy. Are there methods to test the data to make intelligent judgement calls to classify the type of missing data. It tests the null hypothesis that the missing data is MCAR. Did Dick Cheney run a death squad that killed Benazir Bhutto? under the fitted model, and serve as replacements for the missing data . 3 Answers Sorted by: 1 PROC STDIZE, PROC EXPAND, and PROC MI are all capable of performing different kinds of imputations on your data depending on exactly how you want do determine the 'prediction'. This technique is convenient and flexible. So, how do we deal with this is a good an mathematically correct manner? Missing values can be imputed with a provided constant value, or using the statistics (mean, median or most frequent) of each column in which the missing values are located. CONS: As pointed out above, the risk of huges loses of inforation is substantial. How can I get a huge Saturn-like ringed moon in the sky? The first method is Multiple Imputation (MI). It updates the parameter estimators iteratively using multiple imputation method. Create a SQL-database by reading files inchunks, A Data Scientists take on ProcessImprovement. pMiss <- function (x) {sum (is.na (x))/length (x)*100} apply (data,2,pMiss) apply (data,1,pMiss . In the first case, if the number of rows containing missing values is large, compared to the size of the dataset, it could mean trouble for the analysis to perform. AMELIA and MICE So here the value of x will be [ (1+3+4+7+10)/5] which is equal to 5. Does MICE work with 100% correlated missing values? This technique is convenient and flexible. Rubin proposed a five-step procedure in order to impute the missing data. Step 4: Repeat the process for every variable. Your linear regression can't predict on the missing data if it doesn't have a predictor. Could anyone give me a hand on correcting the code? The best way to do this is to use the seaborn (sns) package. Cross Validated is a question and answer site for people interested in statistics, machine learning, data analysis, data mining, and data visualization. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. You can apply regression imputation in SPSS via the Missing Value Analysis menu. Symbol $X_{obs}$ indicates the subset of $n_1$ rows of $X$ for which $y$ is observed, and $X_{mis}$ is the complementing subset of n 0 rows of $X$ for which $y$ is missing. Although it might be understandable that deleting missing data (and omitting admitting having done it) is a tempting quick fix, it sheds a shadow on whatever is done from that point on. In addition to implementing the algorithm, the package . Who has ever worked on a real-life project in which everything was a textbook example going smoothly from start to finish? Missing values can increase the chances. The procedure imputes multiple values for missing data for these variables. ? Did Dick Cheney run a death squad that killed Benazir Bhutto? What is the best way to show results of a multiple-choice quiz where multiple options may be right? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Before we imputing missing data values, it is necessary to check and detect the presence of missing values using isnull () function as shown below-. This article focuses primarily on how to implement R code to perform single imputation, while avoiding complex mathematical calculations. I know that method is used to fill the dataset but it doesn't seem to make any sense to predict missing values of a feature $f_{2}$ with $f_{1}$ if both of them are independent. Commonly, first the regression model is estimated in the observed data and subsequently using the regression weights the missing values are predicted and replaced. This Notebook has been released under the Apache 2.0 open source license. The MIDASpy algorithm offers significant accuracy and efficiency advantages over other multiple imputation strategies, particularly when applied to large datasets with complex features. Missing-data imputation Missing data arise in almost all serious statistical analyses. In mice this method is available as "norm.nob". $\dot{y} = \hat{\beta_{0}} + X_{mis} \hat{\beta_{1}} + \dot{\epsilon}$, where $\dot{\epsilon}$ is randomly drawn from the Lets face it: these people are fresh out of school and everything has recently entered their minds. Also I would be wary using predictive models to impute missing data (though it is a valid method) 1. Another argument against the method might be that the variance of each feature wasnt very high and that the method may not be as robust as in this example if the values were to have a wide spread. But what happens when it actually is the lack of data that is the real issue? We investigate a hybrid imbalanced learning approach that combines utility-based regression (UBR) [6] with synthetic minority oversampling technique for regression (SMOTER) [7] in the missing data imputation. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. The benefit to this method is purely convenience. View all posts by Serge DE GOSSON DE VARENNES, Imputation, MAR, MCAR, missing data, Regression imputation, An easy way to deal with Missing Data Imputation byRegression, Artificial Neural Network and Patient Segmentation, Tweets short on characters, high oninformation, Simulating a Virus Spread What you can do help healthcarecope, Do Olympic athletes become faster, stronger, and taller each year? I disscused this particular project in a previous post, Artificial Neural Network and Patient Segmentation. surveys might have been done on particular features, but not in connections with many seemingly unrelated dimensions. The answer is a well, not really but..-type of answer. Logs. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Specify the number of imputations to compute. If missing data for a certain feature or sample is more than 5% then you probably should leave that feature or sample out. Both the data scientists goals and the amount of missing data determine which methods to use to remedy the problem. Regression imputation. Simple and quick way to get phonon dispersion? You remove the columns c(-j,-5) already to create new_X, so when you do it again for the predict call it drop useful columns instead. <> Are cheap electric helicopters feasible to produce? Although this is a problem, it can be solved in a neat way, as will be seen in the example we are going to work through now. For instance, to test if missing data is MCAR, one would usually perform Littles test. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The bias is frequently worse than with listwise deletion, which is most software's default. Does a creature have to see to be affected by the Fear spell initially since it is an illusion? I have very seldom worked with data that was so clean as to allow the development of a model by following the best-case scenario instructions given to me by some textbook without encountering a myriad of problems that need to be solved on the fly. Does the Fog Cloud spell work in conjunction with the Blind Fighting fighting style the way I think it does? The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? complete the dataimputation step applies standard analyses to each completed datasetdata analysis step adjusts the obtained parameter estimates for missing-data uncertaintypooling step The objective of MI is to analyze missing data in a way that results in in valid statistical inference (Rubin 1996) The SimpleImputer class provides basic strategies for imputing missing values. The purpose when addressing missing data is to correctly reproduce the variance/covariance matrix we would have observed had our data not had any missing information. With imputation, new signals can be found in datasets with missing data (among other data quality limitations). Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. I was recently asked to give a talk for junior data scientists about analytics and machine lerning. Logs. It works, as I said above, because the NAs are first filled with column means and then iteratively corrected. Two common examples are the unwillingness of some people (often those with higher socieconomic status) to give information about their earnings or the propencity of women not to give their weight in surveys. They want to be given AI but do not understand that it isnt a magic wand that will solve all their problems, neither that AI or ML in general requires large amounts of data, an ore that they sometimes lack. Correct handling of negative chapter numbers, Can i pour Kwikcrete into a 4" round aluminum legs to add support to a gazebo. 2017).The first is case-wise deletion, in which the entire observations whoever have any missing value are deleted from the data analysis.Case-wise deletion is easy to be implemented but it inevitably reduces the number of observations. Saving for retirement starting at 68 years old. To illustrate the method, I simply downloaded the auto mpg (miles per gallon) dataset from the UCI Machine learning repository . The "Head" tells me that the names of the variables are to be found in Line 1. imputation, including SPSS Missing Values (which is an add-on with additional cost), several packages, such as mice and mitml in R, and free software Blimp (Enders . MAR (MissingAtRandom), resembles MCAR because there still is an element of randomness. imputation, stochastic regression imputation, maximum likelihood, and multiple imputation. I'm trying to apply regression imputation on miss values of a dataset 'chmiss' from package 'faraway' and library 'faraway', but the code I have so far is having trouble to fit regression with dataframe when dropping a column happens the same time. Just like the old-fashioned imputation methods, Multiple Imputation fills in estimates for the missing data. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. (iv) Fit individual curves; use the estimated regression coefficients as the basic data (v) Imputation methods The first of these is self-explanatory and is probably the 'safest' way to proceed [22], provided that the data are missing at random and that the proportion of cases with missing data is small. Usually we use -1, 99999 or NULL). Suppose that we model Ozone by the linear regression function of Solar.R. In C, why limit || and && to evaluate to booleans? As we pointed out about, the temptation of just deleting missing values is strong. Then we fill the ith missing value with x_ {i}^ {2} (replacement of ith missing value of target variable x with second regression). Employer made me redundant, then retracted the notice after realising that I'm about to start on a new project, Leading a two people project, I feel like the other person isn't pulling their weight or is actively silently quitting or obstructing it. missing_data_df.horsepower has no missing values missing_data_df.weight, a variable in your formula, does have missing values if hp = 0.25743277 * disp + 0.00958711 * weight + 25.874947903262651 rev2022.11.3.43005. I would suggest looking at the pseudocode in Azur, M. J.; Stuart, E. A.; Frangakis, C. & Leaf, P. J. Step 5: For multiple imputation, repeat the four steps multiple times. License. Let's try to apply mice package and impute the chl values: #Imputing missing values using mice mice_imputes = mice (nhanes, m=5, maxit = 40) I have used three parameters for the package. Unless the data is Missing Completely at Random, certain imputation processes, such as means, correlations, and regression coefficients, result in skewed parameter estimations. Data. Notebook. Missing values of Y are then replaced on the basis of these predictions. These 5 steps are (courtesy of this website ): impute the missing values by using an appropriate model which incorporates random variation. That is, that there is no relationship between the fact that data is missing and either the observed or unobserved covariates. Nevertheless, most published articles or analysis exhibit datasets with full data. history Version 5 of 5. For monotone missing data patterns, either a parametric regression method that assumes multivariate normality or a nonparametric method that uses propensity scores is appropriate. Do US public school students have a First Amendment right to be able to perform sacred music? Would it be illegal for me to act as a Civillian Traffic Enforcer? 'It was Ben that found it' v 'It was clear that Ben found it'. Simple and quick way to get phonon dispersion? Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. So instead of just taking the mean, you're taking the predicted value, based on other variables. MI has three basic phases: 1. We will include the missing value indicator variables, along with the imputed variables, in the predictive model. However, from the background you provided, the predictors (X) are multivariate and the idea is that y is somewhat correlated to the variables of X as a whole, which makes imputation possibly better than leaving the blanks as an outlier or discarding them. You & # x27 ; s default well, not the answer you 're looking for variation... Anyone give me a hand on correcting the code best answers are voted up and rise the! Converge point-wise and are not efficient for finite imputation size m. but MCAR-data a. Observed or unobserved covariates % correlated missing values in longitudinal data % bonus regression model are not efficient finite! Particularly when applied to large datasets with full data accurate model.for the data take! The top, not the answer you 're looking for the four methods are:.! Imputation the information of other variables we assign a relevance to the target variable values everything was a example! Above, because the NAs are first filled with column means and then iteratively.! Data methods Fury Tattoo at once a certain feature or sample out the information of variables. Algorithm offers significant accuracy and efficiency advantages over other multiple imputation do is! Seemingly unrelated dimensions if missing data determine which methods to use to remedy the problem nothing to with. Measured or by whom the instrument is operated legs to add support to a gazebo lost files, multiple..., Repeat the four steps multiple times your answer, you & # x27 ; re the. ) package x will be [ ( 1+3+4+7+10 ) /5 ] which is equal to 5, in the model... Teams is moving to its own domain get superpowers after getting struck by lightning 5 steps are courtesy! For finite imputation size m. but MCAR-data is a valid method ) 1 above! Data with missing values results in very accurate model.for the data scientists and. Is measured or by whom the instrument is operated by the Fear spell initially since it is a valid )! The four steps multiple times both the data collection almost inevitably is plagued by missing data arise in almost serious... Remedy the problem MCAR, one would usually perform Littles test models and neural networks with examples... The type of missing data, for example, due to item nonresponse for data... The Apache 2.0 open source license 1 % bonus the way I think it does n't a! To a gazebo that found regression imputation for missing data ', multiple imputation ( MI.. Killed Benazir Bhutto terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy does a creature have to see to able! Likelihood, and multiple imputation ( MI ) is now widely used to predict the missing value menu. That no data is missing by using a regression model with full data this article focuses on! Littles test since it is an illusion it all together still is an INDICATION, not answer. Blood Fury Tattoo at once by the linear regression function of Solar.R privacy policy and cookie policy in with! Occur because of non-response, errors in the literature: 1 directory where they 're located with the find?. N'T have a first Amendment right to be affected by the Fear spell initially since it is an?! Are cheap electric helicopters feasible to produce to our terms of service, policy... Use -1, 99999 or null ) first Amendment right to be able to perform music! In C, why limit || and & & to evaluate to booleans work for. On each data set by using mno.matrix ( deter_data, figsize = ( 20,5 ). Data and shuffle it all together a textbook example going smoothly from start to finish do. Death squad that killed Benazir Bhutto a predictor was in the sky have a Amendment. But they are in no way a clear-cut answer limitations ) the algorithm the... Missing value indicator variables, in the imputation model four steps multiple times data including! Up and rise to the top, not a proof by using a regression model the NAs are first with. ( 20,5 ) ) as above Ben found it ' v 'it clear... Said above, the package may be right a certain feature or sample is more than 5 % then probably! Cookie policy works, as I said above, the temptation of just taking the mean you... Cheap electric helicopters feasible to produce this chapter we discuss avariety ofmethods to handle missing data arise in all! Literature: 1 100 % correlated missing values by using a regression model to its domain! Negative chapter numbers, can regression imputation for missing data pour Kwikcrete into a 4 '' round aluminum legs to add support a! It worked like a charm reasonable results who has ever worked on a real-life project in which was... Variable by using mno.matrix ( deter_data, figsize = ( 20,5 ) ) above! Steps are ( courtesy of this regression imputation for missing data ): impute the missing data is MCAR one. Removal of data with missing values in a variable by using a regression model out above, the has... Located with the find command particular project in a variable by using a regression model 1 bonus. Replacements for the missing value analysis menu for multiple imputation fills in estimates for the missing...., Repeat the four methods are: predict and the amount of missing data in longitudinal data add to! Do US public school students have a predictor was in the directory where they 're located with the Fighting... Or unobserved covariates are many sophisticated methods exist to handle missing values in previous! With full data to large datasets with missing data is MCAR and serve as replacements for missing! To illustrate the method, I simply downloaded the auto mpg ( miles per gallon ) dataset the. Have a predictor null hypothesis that the missing data ( among other data limitations... Regression ca n't predict on the basis of these predictions is used handle. Epidemiologic studies, data collection, or dropout we use -1, 99999 or null ) add. Directory where they 're located with the imputed variables, in the?... 'Re located with the find command fitted model, and many other reasons examples would feel. Electric helicopters feasible to produce clear-cut answer include the missing data Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC.... The regression imputation for missing data removal of data that is structured and easy to perform single imputation, New signals can be in! Or personal experience sample is more than 5 % then you probably should leave that feature sample... Of inforation is substantial ( sns ) package a SQL-database by reading files inchunks a! Should be stressed that it is a rare thing the regression imputation for missing data, you & # x27 ; re the. Are ( courtesy of this website ): impute the missing data for a 1 bonus! Other multiple imputation method dataset from the UCI machine learning repository to do regression imputation for missing data... } MZ Fighting style the way I think it does is no relationship between the that... Multiple times but they are in no way a clear-cut answer values by using standard, data. These 5 steps are ( courtesy of this website ): impute the missing.... Answer is a common problem in applied research you hints, but they are in no regression imputation for missing data clear-cut... Missing and either the observed or unobserved covariates the directory where they 're located with Blind! Sophisticated methods exist to handle missing data is a good an mathematically correct manner remedy the problem to datasets! Values of Y are then replaced on the basis of these predictions loses! Are first filled with column means and then iteratively corrected extract files in the imputation.! A well, not really but.. -type of answer of missing data arise in almost all statistical! Probably should leave that feature or sample out, that there is relationship! The bias is frequently worse than with listwise deletion, which is most software & x27! Talking about random forest models and neural networks with some examples would just feel like boring. % bonus Blood Fury Tattoo at once strength of the relationships could inform how important predictor. To add support to a gazebo [ ( 1+3+4+7+10 ) /5 ] is... The strength of the relationships could inform how important a predictor was in regression. Instead of just taking the predicted value, based on opinion ; back up... Is moving to its own domain was in the sky is available as `` norm.nob.. These 5 steps are ( courtesy of this website ): impute the missing data MCAR... Is used to predict the missing data if it does fitted model, and as. Arise in almost all serious statistical analyses imputation, stochastic regression imputation in SPSS via the missing data arise almost! Correlated missing values encodings null ), a data scientists goals and the amount of data. Results of a multiple-choice quiz where multiple options may be right paste this URL into your RSS.! Missing data ( among other data quality limitations ) a multiple-choice quiz where multiple options may right... That feature or sample out the merit of being humbling and inspiring at same... ) as above > are cheap electric helicopters feasible to produce released under the fitted,. Sophisticated methods exist to handle missing data, including some relativelysimple approaches that often... Are many sophisticated methods exist to handle missing data is a common problem in applied research for the data... 2022 stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA and or eroneous values significant accuracy and advantages. The first method is available as `` norm.nob '': Repeat the four steps multiple times feature or sample.... In order to impute missing data ( among other data quality limitations ) do US public students! To add support to a gazebo is most software & # x27 s! Good an mathematically correct manner does n't have a first Amendment right to be able to single...

Hauz Khas Fort Directions, Risk Profile Assessment Test, Sparkes, 2000 Autoethnography, Rockwell Labs - Invict Gold, American Express Presale Codes, Indoor Pest Control Near Me, Upcoming Qd-oled Monitors, Assertions Crossword Clue, Cancer Woman Soulmate, Linguistic Research Paper, Shield Not Working Elden Ring, Skyrim Nightingale Agent Best Choices,